Thursday, August 26, 2010

Bam!

Well, can I describe my frustration to you? Of course I can; that's why I have a blog! I am beginning to understand the frustration of the emergency medicine physician: triage but no admitting privileges. Pain, pain, pain.

Basically, it works like this. Because we're in training, the MFM fellows cannot bill for labor floor inpatient care. We can, however, bill for outpatient care, so we manage triage on our calls. But this is progressively making me crazier as I have more an dmore problems with insubordination.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 I was staffing triage last week. It was not crazy busy, but it was steady. A very sweet 24 year old primip* came in - a walk-in patient, naturally - at 39 and 5/7 weeks with contractions every 8 minutes. I'm in the room with her, and both she and her boyfriend are smiling and chatting, and I know she's not in labor before I even examine her. But then, I ask my usual four questions**, and hey: she's been leaking fluid for four days. Hmm.

I explain to patients all the time that we have three, or possibly four, tests to diagnose ruptured membranes. We look in the vagina to see pooling; we test the fluid from the vagina for its pH and see whether it turns nitrazine paper blue. And we look under the microscope at a dried slide of the fluid - amniotic fluid crystallizes in these beautiful ferns (they look kind of like snowflakes on glass; it's quite pretty.) If those are negative, then I usually do a quick look with the ultrasound to confirm that the amniotic fluid around the baby in utero is normal.

So I examine her, and there's a pool. It's water. It's nitrazine blue. But it does not fern. While waiting for the ferning, I scan her, and her amniotic fluid is normal. Hmm.

Regardless, there's that pool, It's clearly coming from the cervix, it's clearly water.  I tell her that all the tests don't match up but I am pretty sure she's ruptured her membranes, and although I do not like to induce primiparous women, I am uncomfortable sending her home. There are risks to an induction as well, especially because it's her first baby, but given that I think she ruptured her membranes a while ago, I really recommend induction.

We talk, we discuss, questions are answered. She would like to stay for induction. I ask the nurses to admit her to L&D. Done.

Except. Well. The attending on the floor calls me. Why are you admitting her, she asks. Well, I say, I think she's ruptured and been ruptured for a few days. But, she says, why is the fluid around the baby normal? Why is there no ferning? Bodies are weird, I say. I agree that it doesn't totally make sense. I talked this over with the patient, I say. Regardless of the mixed data, I think she's ruptured.

What I didn't say was: This is my judgement. This is why I am here.  This is the diagnosis I have made. If you are uncomfortable with that, feel free to come examine the patient on your own. I am not discharging this patient to home.  If you are going to treat me like someone who is not trustworthy, then I would prefer to go home and put Smoosh to bed, and not stay up all night, thank you very much.

What I did say was: I am uncomfortable discharging this patient. If you would like, I will happily repeat the speculum exam and see if I can get ferning.

Twenty minutes later, the nurse tells me that the patient is grossly ruptured, with fluid all over the bed. Because I know that I will be asked, I swab some fluid, and finally see ferns. The patient is admitted, and I want to scream.

______________________________________________________

To clarify: I am an attending. I have been for many years. Before fellowship, I was on my own for 2 years, and did just fine.  I am fully capable of handling this - and many, many other things - by myself, without supervision. But the side effect of this triage job, and of returning to training in general is that I get "supervised" for many things that I already know, not just Maternal-Fetal Medicine subspecialty things. There's an element of protection in this: I am supposed to be learning, after all! But also an incredible element of condescension, leading to insanity and snarkiness on my part.


*Having her first baby
**Contractions? Leaking of fluid? Bleeding from the vagina? Baby moving? You want 3 nos and a yes, and if so, have effectively ruled out most obstetrical pathology.

8 comments:

  1. gevalt. I get annoyed when no one listens to me (especially about other people's well-being. ask me sometime about the day I almost lost my job over refusing to take a kid into the pool who I just knew was about to start seizing and while the dept head sent me to the office to cool down someone else took him in and he seized for about two minutes in the water.)

    But in the end I'm only a B.A. You're an MD! At what point do you have enough training and enough weight around there that people believe your intuitions enough even when they don't follow textbook protocol? I guess I don't understand the hospital hierarchy...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, in my residency program the interns get treated better than that. I never know why - but some times the fluid just doesn't fern! Ugh! Good luck and know that every day is one day closer to attendinghood.

    ReplyDelete
  3. OK, random uninformed scientist guess, but does the fluid fern because of the proteins in it make nice ordered aggregates, and maybe some people have different variants of the proteins that aggregate less well?

    Anyway, what I really wanted to tell you is that I have the basic frustration of having responsibility without authority, too. I joke that I have reached the pinnacle of that state, since I am now both a project manager and a middle manager. But at least no one's health hangs directly on my decisions....

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well, what did she want you to do? Send the poor soul home and wait till she was infected?

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Mamadoc: I know. I think she just wanted all the data to match, and wouldn't we all, and doesn't it sometimes not? Hence my judgement call - why you pay me the big bucks - and hence my fury at being questioned.

    ReplyDelete
  6. C, so that's my question: is there a point at which the other docs start trusting you even when the data don't all look textbook perfect, or is the culture such that you are just never above being second guessed even by people who don't have your expertise?

    ReplyDelete
  7. It seems so hard to go back to training after being an attending. Yes we all get second-guessed by other docs, but once you are out of training, it is equal opportunity second guessing. When I was in training I expected that my decisions would be overturned some of the time, and i was happy that somebody was looking over my shoulder. After a couple of years of being an attending, that would make me absolutely nutz.

    A while ago, i saw a patient that I thought needed an MRI but it was after 4 pm on a friday so i had to get radiologist approval to get it done because it was after regular MRI hours. The radiologist gave me a really hard time because the patient had been in the hospital for 2 days already, ect (I was only consulted that afternoon so obviously I had nothing to do with the delay) I was relly frustrated by this conversation. I fumed. As a trainee my only choice would have been to suck it up. As an attending I mentioned this to another radiologist that i know well, he called up the department head who made the original radiologist call and apologize. It was totally awkward and i never really wanted the appology or the revenge of it, but it was also a little reassuring that i had moved up in the pecking order.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Emfish, you have put the matter in a nutshell. **you are just never above being second guessed even by people who don't have your expertise**. That is medicine for you! C, I would scream in frustration too. Why can't we respect each other? You help me remember why I am in solo practice rather than an academician.

    ReplyDelete

Followers